Embark Studios is facing backlash over its use of artificial intelligence once again. This time, the controversy involves replacing real esports commentators with AI-generated voices in an official The Finals tournament highlight video. Following criticism from the community, Embark Studios removed the video and issued an apology.
AI Commentators Replace Real Casters
The controversy began after Embark Studios published a highlight video covering the APAC Closed Qualifiers for The Grand Major, an official esports tournament for The Finals.
Instead of using the original commentary from the people who actually worked at the event, the studio used the game’s fictional hosts, Scotty and June. Their voices are generated using artificial intelligence and text-to-speech technology.
The decision quickly drew criticism from the actual commentators. ProtoANZ pointed out that he, TheeHyperactive, and Bluepanda had spent four tournament cycles covering open and closed qualifiers, investing their time, effort, and passion into the events, only to be replaced by AI voices in the official recap.
One particularly frustrating detail was that the AI commentators even repeated some of the phrases originally used by the real casters during the broadcasts.
Bluepanda also expressed disappointment with the studio’s decision. After years of collaboration and repeated assurances that their work was valued, the commentators suddenly found themselves being treated as unnecessary.
Other members of the esports community joined the criticism. Some described the situation as a worrying sign for the industry, raising concerns that similar decisions could eventually cost professional commentators their jobs.
Embark Studios Admits Its Mistake and Removes the Video
Following the backlash, Embark Studios’ Oscar Lundberg issued a public apology.
He explained that the studio had intended to use Scotty and June to introduce more casual players to The Finals esports scene ahead of The Grand Major. However, the team acknowledged that it had failed to properly recognize the people who had actually worked on the tournament broadcasts.
According to Lundberg, leaving out the commentators and other broadcast talent was the wrong decision. Their work deserved to be included and highlighted.
The studio subsequently removed the video and confirmed that the planned recaps for the AMER and EMEA regions would not be released in the same format. Embark also said it would rethink all three videos.
In a separate statement shared with IGN, the company acknowledged that replacing the real commentators with AI voices was not the right call and thanked the community for its honest feedback.
Why Has the Controversy Become So Significant?
This is not the first time Embark Studios has faced criticism over its use of AI in games. The studio has previously encountered backlash over synthetic voices in both The Finals and ARC Raiders.
In ARC Raiders, for example, some character voice lines were generated using text-to-speech technology. The developers explained that recording every possible line for constantly changing gameplay situations would be impractical and time-consuming.
However, following criticism, the studio began bringing professional voice actors back to record some of the dialogue. Embark CEO Patrick Söderlund previously acknowledged that a professional actor delivers better results than AI. PC Gamer+1
The latest situation is different from those earlier debates. This is not simply about using AI to generate additional in-game dialogue. Instead, the technology was used to replace people who had actually participated in covering a competitive esports event.
That distinction is a major reason why the reaction has been so strong. Professional commentators contribute much more than spoken words. Their emotional delivery, spontaneous reactions, and experience help create the atmosphere that makes esports broadcasts engaging.
There are also questions about how appropriate it is to reuse real commentators’ phrases and elements of their work in content where they themselves have been replaced by AI-generated voices.
What Does This Mean for the Future of Esports?
The Finals controversy highlights how complicated the integration of artificial intelligence into the gaming industry remains.
AI can certainly speed up content production, simplify the creation of additional voice lines, and reduce costs. However, audiences may react very differently when the technology is used to replace professionals who were directly involved in producing the original content.
In this case, Embark Studios ultimately abandoned its original approach following criticism from commentators and the gaming community.
But the incident raises a much broader question: where should the industry draw the line between using AI as a supporting tool and replacing human workers?
There is no universal answer yet. However, the situation surrounding The Finals demonstrates that technological capabilities are not the only thing that matters to players and industry professionals. Respect for the people who make esports events possible matters too.




